Are Burka Ladies a Threat to Mainstream Orthodox Women?

burqa-family-beit-shemesh

This is a response to a discussion on the Face-Covering Jewish Women from Beit Shemesh on a private Orthodox Jewish forum. The poster, —œCapital Chick— from Canada, gave permission to post. I have edited it slightly. Capital Chick is responding to forum members who argue that this is none of our business, and the hyper-modest women won't affect the lives of "mainstream" Jewish women in any way. I disagree that these women are not a threat. I think that they are. I think that it is the height of political correctness and moral relativism to claim, within this Jewish context, "to each his own" or "everyone is correct in their personal interpretation of halacha". This is wrong, … [Read more...]

Face-Covering Families in Beit Shemesh: A Destructive Cult?

jewish-family-burqa-beit-shemesh_thumb.jpg

These pictures, from Nahar Hayarden Street in Beit Shemesh, were posted on Rotter.net. The youngest one looks about four years old. They are covered from head to toe in black, except for the youngest who enjoys a red, white and blue print with a blue head-covering. The girls from this group, which the author of the piece calls a cult, attend their own school in Jerusalem. The author of the article claims that this family is part of a cult that is spreading like wildfire, with new families joining each week. Here's a translation of the Rotter forum post. I have no way of verifying whether the information is accurate: Details of the Cult, Regulations, and Stringencies: Every … [Read more...]

Cashier Denied Employment in Haredi Supermarket Because of Wig

assortment of long wigs

A few days ago the haredi internet forum Behadrei Haredim reported on a Chabad woman who lost her job as a cashier in a haredi supermarket, because she wore a wig instead of a scarf or snood. As I've mentioned several times, the "hyper-tzniut" movement discourages wigs. Women are frequently approached in the street, or even at their doors, and told that their wig is delaying the Messiah. Blogger Risa's husband was given a lecture on the topic when Risa wasn't even wearing  a wig. Radio host Menachem Toker called the supermarket, Chesed Le-Alafim, and spoke with the manager. The manager claims that the cashier had never been formally hired so she wasn't technically fired. (However, … [Read more...]

Update: The Edah Discourages Veils, Etc.

pashkburqa_thumb.jpg

According to the latest pashkevil (wall poster), posted by Rafi of Life in Israel, the Edah Charedit warns women against adopting new customs, going against their husbands, wearing strange clothing including veils, and dressing up their daughters according to various stringencies. The Edah Haredit is a stringent, anti-Zionist rabbinical court in Jerusalem with a large following. The first paragraph of the pashkevil warns against clothing that is too straight or tight. Here is my translation of the second paragraph: At the same time, one must be careful not to wear strange and weird coverings and clothing (and likewise, veils etc.) especially if it is against the opinion of the … [Read more...]

Update: Edah Claims to Object to Shawls, Poster False

Jerusalem on wall poster advocating shawls for all women

Update: According to comments on the Kikar Shabbat website, the date of the posters recommending shawls for all wmoen is from six years ago. Someone must have reprinted and posted them. The Edah Haredit claims they are not behind the current poster. They claim to have considered prohibiting "shalim" altogether, but in the end did not go that far. The other day I wrote that husbands of women who cover their faces requested that the Edah haredit rule against the practice. Miriam Shaviv from the Jewish Chronicle reports that it will soon. But in the meantime, a poster went up with a ruling that all women should wear shalim (redidim). But it was six years old. Background on … [Read more...]

Haredi Women Advised to Sit on a Separate Bench from Immodestly Dressed Women

Neve Yaakov: Immodest and Modest Women Asked to Sit Separately

According to the religious Zionist weekly Matzav Haruach, the following sign appeared in a playground in the haredi neighborhood of Neve Yaakov in Jerusalem: According to the suggestion of our teacher the great rabbi H. Kanievsky, women are requested as follows, to divide seating in the city according to groups of women. Women dressed appropriately (wide clothes, a properly covered neck, a modest scarf [MiI: to cover hair]) will sit on separate benches. Women dressed immodestly [bepritzut] Heaven forbid, (tight clothes/open collar/bandana) will sit by themselves. And in this merit the women [MiI: there's no question as to which women, even though the wording is vague] will merit viable … [Read more...]

Hyper-Tzniut Fashions for Young Girls

IMG_8040

Hyper-Tzniut at the Jerusalem Zoo While the face-covering phenomenon seems to have died down, shalim, capes or cloaks worn over the shoulders to disguise the contour of the  body, are still popular. I saw many women in shalim during our visit to the Biblical Zoo in Jerusalem, along with the two girls pictured above who looked about 7 and 10 years old. In my next post I'll share thoughts about a shal-wearing mother nursing her baby on a park bench. Click here for more posts on tzniut, or Jewish modesty. … [Read more...]

Face-Covering Mother of Twelve Convicted of Child Abuse

The trial of Bruria Keren, the face-covering mother of 12 who started a movement encouraging hyper-tzniut (extreme modesty), has been convicted of abusing six of her twelve children. Keren attracted the attention of the press in December 2007 because she covered her face, wore multiple layers of clothes, refused to speak while men were present, and persuaded other women to do likewise. Shortly after this "movement" became known in the press, she was arrested for severe child abuse. Here you can find photographs and links to more posts on the subject. According to Ynet, Keren's lawyer brought expert witnesses who recommended psychiatric care for his client, "whose voice I never … [Read more...]

Thoughts on Face-Covering from Resident of Arab Emirates

"Autumn" left the following comment on the "Burka Wedding" post, in response to a comment by Ora:Ora wrote:"I think there's a big problem with covering the face. It's dehumanizing. I don't know what research, if any, has been done on the subject, but I would think that not seeing a someone's face would make it easier to beat or otherwise abuse them."Autumn:I agree with this, also it allows those with covered face to get away with rude behavior as well. I live in a Gulf Arab Country and a lot of women choose to cover their face with either a niqab (which can also be called a burqa - or ninja style as others like to call it) or a full veil. I have noticed that many (but of course not all) of … [Read more...]

Judge’s Garb an Issue in Child Abuse Trial

Ynet has news on the trial of the mother of twelve from Beit Shemesh who has been accused of child abuse.The mentally handicapped son is scheduled to testify. In an unusual move, the judge and lawyers will wear civilian clothing, because the traditional black cloaks normally required by law might remind the son of his mother and scare him.The article refers to other dramas in the six-month long trial. A month and a half ago, the lawyer of the accused claimed the prison system was condemning her client to death by not providing her with vegan meals. [The early articles written about her discuss her interest in nutrition, and I know a woman who attended a class she gave on the … [Read more...]